Pablo Romero
The Coloniality of Underdevelopment
Why are some countries rich and others poor? In this learning module, learners will explore how colonization impacted developing countries today, and how the concepts of “developed” and “underdeveloped” have also been shaped by colonial histories.
This learning module highlights the significance of European imperialism on economic and political failures across developing countries today. Poverty is a huge issue today, but it must be understood in terms of the poverty traps, corrupt political institutions, and subsequent economic pitfalls that were shaped by European imperialism. I focus this module on countries in Africa, which are some of the most deeply impacted by poverty today. By providing historical context; detailing the impact of colonialism on political and economic institutions over time; and applying what we have learned to contemporary examples, this module has a high potential for student engagement. After completing the module, learners will be able to better understand how colonialism impacted the development of institutions in a post-Columbian world and apply these impacts to developing countries today.
Structure
This module is organized as a collegiate, seminar-discussion-based module. Learners should expect to spend approximately 2 weeks on this module. Each week will have 2 sets of assigned readings, designed for twice-weekly class meetings.
The module is divided into 2 parts of 1 week each. Part 1 dives into how colonization in the past affected inclusive and extractive political and economic institutions across Africa and the Americas. This submodule will also describe the subsequent economic effects on these places when colonialism was occurring. The second half of part 1 will focus more on the present, discussing why economic equality is so widespread today and how European imperialism has affected the political and economic development of countries in the Global South.
Part 2 explains how poor political institutions caused by colonialism force developing countries into poverty traps. By providing specific examples—such as Sierra Leone’s corrupt government (a former British colony) and fossil fuel industry in Africa—this part effectively captures the shadow of colonialism in today’s developing world.
I advise for these readings to be completed in this order so that proper historical context can be set and readers can understand key concepts, like inclusive and extractive institutions, before learning about present examples that followed as a consequential result. While these readings are recommended to be read in this order, the pace at which they are read can be changed to meet student and class needs accordingly. By this, I mean that learners can engage with this material over a period longer than 2 weeks. Depending on preference, the structure can also be swapped so that economic inequality today and poverty in developing countries comes first. They can then tie this back to European colonialism.
Pablo Romero is majoring in Global Studies and Economics at the University of Chicago.
Learning Resources
Legacies of European Colonization Today
Robinson, J. & Acemoğlu, D. (2017, January 30). “The Economic Impact of Colonialism.” VoxEU CEPR
This article describes how economic inequality is a path-dependent outcome of historical processes. It dives into European colonialism and its impact on the industrial revolution and subsequent economic development.
This article discusses the impact of colonialism on developing countries today through the lens of resource endowment—specifically, fossil fuels.
Acemoglu, D. & Robinson, J. A. (2013). Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty. Crown Business (Chapters 3 and 12)
This book delves into the question of why so much economic inequality exists today. Among other things, the book explains how small differences in institutions create drastically different economic outcomes over time.
Colonization and the Poverty Trap
Jalusic, V. (2016). “The European Legacy in Africa (The African Legacy in Europe).” Eurozine
This text contends that European colonization in Africa has resulted in political institutions that fail on terms that are also set by colonizers. The article discusses Africa’s inability to grow because of the effects of European colonialism that have led to post-colonial regimes that are corrupt, inefficient, and totalitarian.
Alabdulwahed, Z. (2020, June 8). Poverty in Africa and the Western Colonization. ArcGIS StoryMaps
This article describes the historical and systematic causes of poverty in developing countries in Africa. The article poses questions on the relationship between European imperialism and poverty today and includes both maps and visual data sources.